Hello! I'm Afoma.
  • Book Reviews
    • Picture book
    • Chapter Books
    • Middle-Grade
    • Graphic Novels
    • Young Adult
    • Adult Fiction
    • Adult Non-Fiction
  • Book Lists
    • Picture Book Lists
    • Middle Grade Book Lists
    • Book Lists by Theme
    • Book Lists by Grade
    • Audiobook Recommendations
  • Join My Newsletter!
  • Go to the Blog
  • Summer Reading
  • Work with Me
    • Review & Promotion Policy
    • School Visits

Reading Middle Grade

Books for Kids and Grown Ups

  • Book Reviews
    • Picture book
    • Chapter Books
    • Middle-Grade
    • Graphic Novels
    • Young Adult
    • Adult Fiction
    • Adult Non-Fiction
  • Book Lists
    • Picture Book Lists
    • Middle Grade Book Lists
    • Book Lists by Theme
    • Book Lists by Grade
    • Audiobook Recommendations
  • Join My Newsletter!
  • Go to the Blog
  • Summer Reading
  • Work with Me
    • Review & Promotion Policy
    • School Visits

Discussions & Tags · June 21, 2019

What Makes a “Good” Book?

graphic saying what makes a good book

What Makes a Good Book to You?

This is a question I wonder about whenever I read book reviews. It never ceases to fascinate me that one person could love a book so much while another person thinks it was absolute rubbish. Some of the most polarizing books I’ve known in my lifetime include Sally Rooney’s Normal People, Taiye Selasi’s Ghana Must Go, and Tayari Jones’s An American Marriage. I’ve read the latter two and I liked Ghana Must Go, but thought An American Marriage was OK.

What Some People Say

Over the last two years, I ran a bookish interview series (many interviews of which aren’t on this site right now, but will be reuploaded in time). One of the questions I asked was this: What makes a good book to you? These were some of the answers:

I think a book is good when I can feel it. It’s a book with compelling messy characters, an emotionally-true story that sweeps over me, writing that makes me sigh or smile or swear in envy… But a really good book for me is one that makes me want to pause/suspend reality to continue it. – ‘Pemi Aguda

For fiction, I’d say a compelling story with believable, complex characters that I feel emotionally connected to. Sentence-level beauty is important to me as well. – Author Crystal Hana Kim

Personally, I think it depends on what kind of book it is and what it’s trying to achieve. Is it the next great American novel, or is it an escapist fairy tale that gives me a break from everyday life? Of course, there are fundamental principles that all books should include—storytelling, plot, prose, etc.—but I don’t think there’s a set-in-stone group of exact criteria for any given book. Different books achieve different things. That’s one thing I love about literature. – Kendra Winchester of Reading Women

What’s a Good Book to Me?

My definition of a good book is closest to Kendra’s. There are different kinds of “good books.” But ultimately, I demand one main thing of the books I read: hold me captive. But again, captivity styles differ. Some books are meant to be slowly savored, so even if you read them over the course of a month, as long as you finished, they held you captive. It would, of course, be sad for a “thriller” to take me one month to read. I’m a quick reader and can easily finish most books within a week as long as I have the time. Thrillers should be one or two sittings for me (if there’s time), otherwise, they’re dragging.

But that’s just one metric.

Should All Good Books Be “Life-Changing”?

Some people judge books to be good only if they’re life-changing, perspective-shifting, or mind-blowing. I disagree. Unfortunately “rating” systems do not specify, there are several kinds of five-star books. There’s five-star literary fiction, five-star middle-grade, five-star “women’s fiction,” and the like. I’d never hold all those categories to the same standard.

There’s also the emotional component; the heart of the story.

Some books are so emotionally moving that they distract you from the “logistics” of the work. It may be a swoony soaring romance with seriously problematic characters. Or an exciting middle-grade book that allows it’s protagonist to sidestep the consequences of bad behavior. As much as I love emotions, if I finish a book and feel unsettled about any issues, it affects my rating and review.

📖 🎧 Does the Format Matter?

If you enjoy audiobooks, you may have noticed that not every good book is a good audiobook. Can a book’s format really affect your definition of a good book? Totally.

Listen to the wrong book on audio and it could be the most annoying thing ever. Similarly, a book that seems convoluted and hard to read might just come alive with the right audiobook narrator. So, sometimes when I recognize that a book would be better read, I try to take that into consideration in my review. I also urge other readers to try (what I think is) the better format.

[bctt tweet=”What makes a good book? Should all good books be lifechanging? Should all books be held to the same rating standards? Does the format matter? Here’s what I think.” username=”afomaumesi”]

What Makes a Good Book? It’s Really Subjective

Ultimately, a good book often depends on the reader. Books strike us differently because of our values, where we are in life, our moods, the format we’re consuming, and a host of other factors. Does this mean there are no bad books? I’d disagree on this one. Some books are shockingly bad, but the good ones vastly outweigh the bad. 😉

Knowing how subjective tastes and opinions are, it pays to be more thoughtful in the way we process art, especially if we review for a massive audience. It helps to say exactly what we liked and what we didn’t. That way, we can spare each other a bad (for us) book and guide another person to one that’s just right!

I’d love to know what you think though: what makes a good book to YOU? Do you have any specific turn-offs? Are there any good-book “must-haves” for you? Let’s talk! 💬

Don't Forget to Share!

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Pocket
  • Email
  • WhatsApp
  • LinkedIn

Related

Posted In: Discussions & Tags · Tagged: Just for Fun

Join My Newsletter

Like what you just read? Sign up for my Friday kidlit newsletter!

Privacy Policy

You’ll Also Love

My Bookish Life from A – Z
top kid lit blogs 201922 Best Kid Lit Blogs to Follow

Comments

  1. Chinyere Evelyn Ifediora says

    June 24, 2019 at 5:44 am

    Books create an escape for me hence good fiction for me lies in the easy language flow, aspirational characters and somewhere other than my location as the setting.

    Reply
    • Afoma Umesi says

      June 26, 2019 at 7:13 am

      Easy language flow is definitely a plus! And yes, a different location certainly helps fuel the escapism.

      Reply
  2. Marie says

    June 26, 2019 at 2:17 pm

    Ah what an interesting discussion, I love it so much! I feel like, a good book, to me, is held at different standards depending on the genre, just like you perfectly stated. I’ll have different criterias depending on the genre I’m reading for sure and I’m also very very big on emotions. If a book is able to make me feel ALL the things, thanks to the beautiful writing, the story, the characters and more, I know it’s going to be a good book for me 🙂

    Reply
    • Afoma Umesi says

      July 2, 2019 at 8:18 am

      Ah! I understand why emotions are so important to some readers and I definitely feel all the feels too, but I can always see logic too, haha. Thanks for reading and commenting, Marie. I appreciate your support <3

      Reply

What do you think? Leave a comment Cancel reply

Next Post >

REVIEW| SEARCHING FOR SYLVIE LEE

About Me
Hi, I'm Afoma! Thank you for stopping by. Learn more about me here.

a group for kid lit lovers

reading middle grade facebook group

Get 2 Months Free on Scribd

Follow on Bloglovin’

Follow

We’re Social Too!

  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest

Stock photos courtesy of our partners at DepositPhotos 📸

Find me on Instagram

whatafomareads

📚 Sharing the best middle grade (and adult) book recommendations
💌 [email protected] for book publicity (No DMs, please)

Afoma
If you love layered middle grade books that still If you love layered middle grade books that still manage to be fun and relatable and accessible to tweens, don’t miss this fall release! Sometimes I thought I was reading a book for adults! Especially with the tough issues Bishop explores during the Dad chapters, which are told in 3rd person (unlike the girls who narrate in first person)!

#sportsbooks #middlegradebooks #mglit
✨lifetime favorite✨ I’m not a big re-reader ✨lifetime favorite✨

I’m not a big re-reader but if I had to re-read favorite middle grade titles, this would be at the top of my list! Clea is a highly motivated middle schooler who’s finding it harder and harder to keep up with school work. Her thoughts keep jumping around and the only time she can really focus is when she’s playing chess. Soon, she’s diagnosed with ADHD and has to find ways to work with the way her brain functions.

I love the way this book deflates stereotypes about the condition and shows just how much effort people with ADHD have to exert to function in a neurotypical world. With an unforgettable voice and strong themes of friendship, family, and crossing over from childhood to teenage years, Focused is a memorable read. 

I would strongly recommend this one for anyone curious about ADHD, chess lovers, and anyone who’s ever squabbled with a best friend.

Have you read this book? What did you think?

#adhd #bookstagram #mglit
✨how ‘bout a little virtual reality?✨

☀️ Addie has reluctantly moved across the country with her dad for his summer job in the virtual reality industry. He's working on research to use VR for therapeutic purposes, such as helping people cultivate empathy. Addie is not into VR, but that starts to change when she meets Matteo another kid on campus, and tries out VR on her own. Eventually, the two find a helpful use for VR that helps other people.

🥽 I loved the illustration style in this one and while I found the VR setting a bit disorienting, I appreciated the unique lens of the story. The graphic novel format works brilliantly for helping readers appreciate the power of VR. I think with text, it would have just been too much “world-building.” This is more engaging and exciting for kids.

🐢 Lo and Behold is a clever middle grade graphic novel about virtual reality, grief, and parental addiction. Readers who enjoy VR will love this one, but as the Author's Note mentions, it will also be a fantastic introduction for those who, like me, aren't familiar with it. A fun summer read with hints of serious themes.

#mglit #middlegrade #bookstagram
✨surprisingly heartwarming middle grade✨ 🗺 ✨surprisingly heartwarming middle grade✨

🗺️ Ginny’s summer is thrown off when her dad gets a surprise redeployment in the middle of their family’s moving to another city. Then, her geography camp gets canceled. Her sister seems to be making new friends, but no one appears to like Ginny–even when she starts her own geography camp. 

❤️ I loved this book way more than I thought I would (from the synopsis). Ginny has such a great voice and she isn’t always the most likable character but she’s always real. I loved watching her grow throughout the story.

📍This sweet, unique young middle grade book made my heart grow and ache for Ginny and her family as they navigated a season of change. Features illustrations and a new geography fact in each chapter.

#amreading #mglit #middlegrade
My current adult reads! HAPPY TRAVELER is a non- My current adult reads! 

HAPPY TRAVELER is a non-fiction title about making travel work for you and creating enjoyable, memorable experiences. So far, I’m enjoying the author’s musings on travel.

HELLO BEAUTIFUL is a bookstagram darling (need I say more?) and I already know I’ll be reading it for a while. It’s one of those books that really forces you to slow down. The writing is so tender; it feels like the author loves her characters ❤️

#bookstagram #amreading #readersofinstagram
✨growing up is full of bumps on the way✨ 🤓 ✨growing up is full of bumps on the way✨

🤓 Sixth grade is off to a rocky start for Rex. His district moved most of his elementary school to another middle school, his best friend ditches him for the popular crew, and his blurry vision means he has to get clunky new glasses–the only kind his family can afford. 

❤️ This sweet graphic novel for fans of Telgemeier is an ode to middle school, family, and finding your people.

#graphicnovel #middleschoolbooks #kidlit
Do you like to hop on the “buzz train”? I find Do you like to hop on the “buzz train”? I find that buzzy books are often worth the hype. Even the few people who dislike them tend to have STRONG feelings about them 👀 which to me is a sign that the story got to you somehow. Of course, not every book is for every reader — hype or not. I share my tip for finding a hyped book that matches your reading tastes.

Which hyped books did you love? And which ones missed the mark for you?

#reader #bookstagram #unpopularopinions
✨a different kind of sunshine✨ I loved this g ✨a different kind of sunshine✨

I loved this graphic memoir about the author’s time as a counselor at a camp for kids with cancer. It was my first time reading anything by this author and I totally get the appeal.

This one didn’t end up being as sad as I thought it would be but it was very moving, especially because Krosoczka shares newspaper clippings and pictures of one the families with whom he forged a particularly close relationship even until his college years.

If you’re looking for an engaging graphic memoir for older kids ages 11+ this is a great choice.

#graphicnovel #kidlit #yareader
Load More Follow on Instagram
  • Blog
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact

Copyright © 2023 Reading Middle Grade · Theme by 17th Avenue

 

Loading Comments...